Donate to Links
Click on Links masthead to clear previous query from search box
- The real winners of Greece's elections: refugees
1 day 3 hours ago
- New period for the left in Europe
1 day 10 hours ago
1 day 15 hours ago
- On the deal between Syriza and ANEL
2 days 9 hours ago
- Chavez, Tsipras & Co.
3 days 12 hours ago
- Adams sees left-wing coalition, backs debt conference
4 days 9 hours ago
- Another excellent
1 week 7 hours ago
- mediated democracy
1 week 22 hours ago
- SYRIZA snubs Papandreou as KKE digs in heels
2 weeks 13 hours ago
- Retreat from Grexit
2 weeks 1 day ago
Is Australian uranium fuelling Japan’s looming nuclear disaster?
Explosion at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant.
Latest: The British Independent reported on March 16 that four of Japan’s atomic reactors are in dire trouble at once, three threatening meltdown from overheating, and a fourth hit by a fire in its storage pond for radioactive spent fuel; radiation at about 20 times normal levels had been detected in Tokyo.
By Jim Green
March 16, 2011 – Links International Journal of Socialist Renewal – There’s every likelihood that radioactive by-products of Australian uranium have been spewing into the atmosphere from the crippled nuclear reactor plant at Fukushima Daiichi in Japan. Despite being a major uranium supplier to Japan, Australia has turned a blind eye to serious, protracted problems with Japan’s nuclear industry and it’s time for a more responsible approach.
The earthquake and tsunami on March 11 led to the automatic shut-down of the operating nuclear reactors at Fukushima. However the Tokyo Electric Power Company (TEPCO) failed in its duty to maintain back-up electricity supply to run pumps to cool the intensely hot and radioactive nuclear cores. At times the situation has been farcical, as when generators were brought to the site only to find that the plugs didn’t fit. The failure to maintain adequate cooling has led to a raft of problems including explosions, fire and deliberate and uncontrolled releases of radiation.
Earthquakes have affected several nuclear plants in Japan. The most serious was the major 2007 earthquake which led to the shutdown of all of TEPCO’s operating reactors at the Kashiwazaki-Kariwa plant in Niigata − not far from Fukushima, but on the west coast. Radiation was released from two reactor buildings, from a pool containing spent nuclear fuel rods, and from 40 drums of nuclear waste which fell over and lost their lids.
There is a history of distrust surrounding TEPCO. All of TEPCO’s reactors were involved in a 2002 safety data falsification scandal which led to protracted reactor shut-downs for inspections and repairs. The “malpractices” were revealed to have been many and varied and to have been ongoing for as long as 25 years. There have been numerous other incidents of data falsification involving reactors in Japan since the 2002 scandal, and further revelations about previous incidents such as TEPCO’s concealment of an emergency shut-down of one of the reactors at Fukushima in 1984.
Distrust of TEPCO grew as a result of the 2007 earthquake in Niigata. The company provided conflicting information over a period of several days, and later acknowledged that the radiation releases would have been reduced if procedures were correctly followed. Nuclear Engineering International reported: “Japan's nuclear industry has been suffering in the glare of negative publicity brought about by revelations that operators had covered up accidents and problems for decades. When it became public knowledge, it was hoped that the public relations disaster that companies were engineering for themselves might lead the wider industry to realise the potential benefits of being more open and honest when problems do crop up. That hope seems to have withered again in Niigata.”
A growing list of accidents are testament to the mismanagement of nuclear power in Japan. Some of the more serious accidents include:
- a sodium leak and fire at the Monju fast breeder in 1995
- a reprocessing waste explosion at Tokai in 1997
- 50 tonnes of primary coolant leaked from a reactor at Tsuruga in 1999, leading to a sharp increase of radiation levels inside the reactor building
- following a criticality accident at a uranium conversion plant at Tokaimura in 1999, two people died and hundreds were irradiated
- in 2001, a water pipe at Hamaoka-1 exploded, releasing radioactive steam into the containment building
- in 2002, 16 workers were irradiated after a water pipe leak at Hamaoka-2.
- at the Mihama nuclear power plant in 2005, a pipe failed due to corrosion, resulting in the deaths of five workers and injuries to six others; the thickness of the failed pipe had not been checked since the plant went into operation in 1976.
A vicious cycle is evident. Mismanagement and slack regulation beget accidents and scandals. The authorities respond with denial and deceit which later gives way to profuse apologies, resignations and solemn promises of improved performance in future. Then it’s business as usual ... mismanagement and slack regulation beget the next accident or scandal and the cycle repeats.
The pattern of mismanagement, accidents and scandals is reflected in public opinion. A 2005 survey by the International Atomic Energy Agency found that just 21 per cent of Japanese citizens support the construction of new reactors; 76 per cent are opposed. Of the 18 countries surveyed, only four were more strongly opposed to the construction of new nuclear reactors.
BHP Billiton and Rio Tinto export uranium from Australia to TEPCO from the Olympic Dam mine in South Australia and the Ranger mines in the Northern Territory. As a major uranium supplier, Australia could play a role in breaking the vicious cycle by making uranium exports conditional on improved management of nuclear plants and tighter regulation. Indeed we have a responsibility to either insist on better performance or to cease uranium exports to Japan. The business-as-usual option makes us complicit in the ongoing fiasco of Japan's nuclear industry.
We are also complicit in fanning regional proliferation tensions by providing Japan with open-ended permission to separate and stockpile weapons-useable plutonium produced in power reactors from Australian uranium. A 1993 US diplomatic cable posed these questions: “Can Japan expect that if it embarks on a massive plutonium recycling program that Korea and other nations would not press ahead with reprocessing programs? Would not the perception of Japan's being awash in plutonium and possessing leading edge rocket technology create anxiety in the region?”
Since 1993, Japan’s plutonium stockpile has grown enormously and regional tensions are sharper than ever. Yet Australia continues to provide open-ended approval for Japan to stockpile plutonium.
And Australia continues to turn a blind eye to the pattern of accidents, scandals and cover-ups.
Hooray for hypocrisy.
[Dr Jim Green is the coordinator of the Choose Nuclear Free project, a collaboration between the Medical Association for Prevention of War, the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons and Friends of the Earth, Australia.]