Chavez ends WSF with call to transcend capitalism

By Cleto A. Sojo

This article was first published at

Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez was warmly received at the 2005 edition of the World Social Forum in Porto Alegre, Brazil, where he held several meetings with local leaders, intellectuals and activists, and gave the closing speech in Gigantinho Stadium. Chávez generated great interest among forum participants, many of whom see him and his project of political transformations being implemented in Venezuela as an inspiration in the struggle for a better world.

The Venezuelan president visited the Lagoa do Junco agrarian settlement in Tapes set up by Brazil's Landless Movement (MST) and later held a press conference with more than 120 media organisations, where he criticised the US government for claiming to lead a fight against terrorism while undermining democracy in Venezuela.

Chávez highlighted the recent creation of Latin American satellite TV network TeleSur, "which will allow us to tell our people's reality in our own words". He added that TeleSur will be at the disposal of the people, not of governments.

The leader added that his country's military forces are undergoing a period of modernisation of their weapon systems and resources, but asserted that this is aimed at defending the country's sovereignty. "Venezuela will not attack anybody, but don't attack Venezuela, because you will find us ready to defend our sovereignty, and the project we are carrying forward", he added.

`The FTAA is death'

During the closing speech at Gigantinho Stadium, the president added that 2005 arrived and the Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA) was not implemented. "The FTAA is death. What they got was mini-FTAAs because US imperialism did not have the strength to impose the neocolonial model of the FTAA."

The president highlighted the Bolivarian Alternative for the Americas (ALBA), a proposal made by Venezuela in opposition to the FTAA and which emphasises social and cultural exchanges above profitbased economic deals. "We can't wait for ten years of sustained economic growth in order to start reducing poverty through the trickle-down effect, as the neo-liberal economic theories propose."

He praised cooperation with Cuba, which, along with several Central American countries, receives Venezuelan oil at below market prices, in exchange for assistance in health care, education, agriculture and other areas. He highlighted that about 20,000 Cuban doctors work in Venezuela at free medical clinics in poor neighbourhoods, and that Venezuela has used a Cuban literacy method approved by UNESCO that has allowed more than 1.3 million Venezuelans to learn how to read and write. He said Venezuela is using Cuban vaccines, which now allow poor children to be vaccinated against diseases such as hepatitis.

The president criticised alleged media distortions about plans by Fidel Castro and him to spread communism in the Americas, overthrow governments and set up guerrillas, "After 10 years, it seems like we haven't been very successful."

"Cuba has its own profile and Venezuela has its own, but we have respect for each other, and we celebrate accords and advance together for the interest of our peoples." He said that any aggression against either country will have to confront the other, "because we are united in spirit from Mexico down to Patagonia".

Chávez said that US-Venezuelan political relations are unhealthy because of "permanent aggression from there". He criticised US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, who recently asserted that Chávez was "a negative force in the region". He said those relations will stay unhealthy as long as the US continues its policies of aggression. "The most negative force in the world today is the government of the United States", he said.

The president criticised the US government for asking other countries to pressure Venezuela in the crisis with Colombia over the kidnapping of a Colombian guerrilla activist in Caracas last December. "Nobody answered their call ... they are more lonely every day." He praised the cooperation of other Latin American countries in the resolution of the crisis, and mentioned that Cuban President Fidel Castro held talks with Colombian President Alvaro Uribe to try to help in resolving the crisis. Chávez agreed to meet Uribe early in February to settle the dispute.

`Imperialism not invincible'

Chávez added that us imperialism is not invincible. "Look at Vietnam, look at Iraq and Cuba resisting, and now look at Venezuela." In reference to the recommendations of some of his close advisers, he said, "Some people say that we cannot say nor do anything that can irritate those in Washington." He repeated the words of Argentine independence hero José de San Martin, "Let's be free without caring what anyone else says."

"When imperialism feels weak, it resorts to brute force. The attacks on Venezuela are a sign of weakness, ideological weakness. Nowadays almost nobody defends neo-liberalism. Up until three years ago, just Fidel and I raised those criticisms at presidential meetings. We felt lonely, as if we had infiltrated those meetings."

He added that those ideological and economic weaknesses will continue to increase. "Just look at the internal repression inside the United States, the Patriot Act, which is a repressive law against US citizens. They have put in jail a group of journalists for not revealing their sources. They won't allow them to take pictures of the bodies of the dead soldiers, many of them Latinos, coming from Iraq. Those are signs of Goliath's weaknesses."

`The south also exists'

He said there were old and new actors on the geopolitical map who are coming into the scene and have an influence on the weaknesses and strengths of US hegemony. "Today's Russia is not Yeltsin's ... there is new Russian nationalism, and I have seen it in the streets of Moscow ... there is a good president, Mr. Putin, at the wheel." He also praised China's fast economic growth, and highlighted the new Spanish socialist government, "which no longer bends its knee in front of US imperialism".

"The south also exists ... the future of the north depends on the south. If we don't make that better world possible, if we fail, and through the rifles of the US Marines, and through Mr. Bush's murderous bombs, if there is no coordination and necessary organisation in the south to resist the offensive of neoimperialism, and the Bush doctrine is imposed upon the world, the world will be destroyed", he said.

Chávez warned of drastic weather changes that would bring catastrophic events if no action is taken soon, in reference to uncontrolled or little-regulated industrial activity. Chávez added that perhaps before those drastic changes take place, there will be rebellions everywhere "because the peoples are not going to accept in peace impositions such as neo-liberalism or colonialism".

`the US people are our brothers'

He added that all empires come to an end. "One day the decay inside us imperialism will end up toppling it, and the great people of Martin Luther King will be set free. The great people of the United States are our brothers, my salute to them."

"We must start talking again about equality. the US government talks about freedom and liberty, but never about equality.

"They are not interested in equality. This is a distorted concept of liberty. the US people, with whom we share dreams and ideals, must free themselves ... A country of heroes, dreamers and fighters, the people of Martin Luther King and Cesar Chávez."

Chávez thanked the Spanish intellectual and editor of Le Monde Diplomatique, Ignacio Ramonet, for saying that Chávez was a new type of leader. He said he is inspired by old types of leaders such as Christ, whom he described as "one of the greatest anti-imperialist fighters, the redeemer of the poor and one of the greatest revolutionaries of the history of the world".

The president also mentioned Venezuela's independence hero Simón Bolivar, Brazil's José Ignacio Abreu Elima, Che Guevara, "that Argentine doctor who travelled through the continent on a motorcycle and who was a witness of the US invasion of Guatemala in 1955, one of the many invasions of the US empire in this continent", and Cuban President Fidel Castro.

`Capitalism must be transcended'

"Every day I become more convinced—there is no doubt in my mind, and as many intellectuals have said—that it is necessary to transcend capitalism. But capitalism can't be transcended from within capitalism itself, but through socialism, true socialism, with equality and justice. But I'm also convinced that it is possible to do it under democracy, but not in the type of democracy being imposed from Washington", Chávez said.

"We have to reinvent socialism. It can't be the kind of socialism that we saw in the Soviet Union, but it will emerge as we develop new systems that are built on cooperation, not competition", he added.

Chávez said that Venezuela is trying to implement a social economy. "It is impossible, within the framework of the capitalist system, to solve the grave problems of the poverty of the majority of the world's population. We must transcend capitalism. But we cannot resort to state capitalism, which would be the same perversion of the Soviet Union. We must reclaim socialism as a thesis, a project and a path, but a new type of socialism, a humanist one, which puts humans and not machines or the state ahead of everything. That's the debate we must promote around the world, and the WSF is a good place to do it."

He added that in spite of his admiration for Argentine revolutionary Che Guevara, Che's methods are not applicable. "That thesis of one, two or three Vietnams, did not work, especially in Venezuela."

The president cited Russian revolutionary Leon Trotsky by saying, "Each revolution needs the whip of the counter-revolution to advance."

He listed actions by the opposition and the US government to drive him out of power. "But we resisted, and now have gone on the offensive. For instance, we recovered our oil industry ... In 2004, from the oil industry budget we utilised $4 billion for social investments, education, health, microcredits, scholarships and housing, aimed at the poorest of the poor, what neo-liberals call a waste of money. But that is not a waste of money because it is aimed at empowering the poor so that they can defeat poverty." He added, "That money before stayed out of Venezuela or just benefited the rich."

He criticised privatisations by saying, "Privatisation is a neo-liberal and imperialist plan. Health can't be privatised because it is a fundamental human right, nor can education, water, electricity and other public services. They can't be surrendered to private capital that denies the people their rights."

Defends Lula

Chávez defended Brazilian President Luis "Lula" Da Silva, who has been sharply criticised by the Latin American left, and who was booed during his speech at the World Social Forum.

"I say this from the bottom of my heart. In Venezuela at the beginning of my presidency, many of my supporters criticised me and asked me to go at a faster pace and be more radical, but I considered that it was not the right moment because each process has several phases and different rhythms that not only have to do with internal situations in each country, but with the international situation at the time.

"So, risking that you will make some strange noise, I want to say that I like Lula, I appreciate him, and he is a good man, of a great heart. He is a brother, a comrade and I send him a hug, my love and affection. I'm sure that with Lula and the people of Brazil, with Nestor Kirchner and the Argentine people, with Tabaré Vasquez and the Uruguayan people, we will be opening the path to realising the dream of a united Latin America."